Sunday morning music


I’m obliged to Kim du Toit, a fellow expatriate South African who, like me, is now an American citizen. A couple of days ago he mentioned on his blog the Genesis hit “Firth of Fifth“, from their fifth studio album “Selling England by the Pound“.  He first linked to a version of the song by former Genesis lead guitarist Steve Hackett, then to an analysis of the piece by a composer in the classical music tradition.  I found both engrossing.

Genesis was, of course, a progressive rock group from the outset.  Classical music influences are evident in a great deal of their music.  (One of the things I dislike most about modern pop, R&B, etc. is their inanity.  They make no effort to rely on the human race’s voluminous musical roots, instead starting with nothing much and going on to nothing at all.  Rap is even worse.)  Drawing on such a rich musical heritage allowed many progressive rock artists (such as Jethro Tull, Mike Oldfield, Strawbs, Yes and many others) to create their melodies and hits, and it shows.

Here are the two performances to which Kim linked.  The first is a music performance, the second a music analysis, so if you don’t like to hear such a detailed breakdown of the music behind the song, you’ll probably want to skip it.

To illustrate just how much classical music roots and themes influenced progressive rock, here are a couple of examples from other groups.  First, Strawbs with their three-part piece “Autumn“, from the album “Hero and Heroine“, possibly their finest prog-rock collection at the height of their powers.

Next, here’s Jethro Tull in a 1969 live performance of “Bouree” from their album “Stand Up“, combining J. S. Bach’s original composition with jazz and rock influences to very good effect.  The piece remained popular for as long as the band toured, with repeated demands for it from audiences around the world.  It changed and evolved as the group did, sometimes being performed as part of an extended medley, but always fluid and fluctuating.

Finally, let’s have something combining traditional folk music, progressive rock leanings, a little jazz and a touch of classical elegance.  British group Traffic released their fourth studio album, “John Barleycorn Must Die“, in 1970.  Here’s the title track.  Listen to the background instrumentation and how it progresses from simple to more complex, yet never loses its folk roots.

Thanks, Kim, for the inspiration for this morning’s blog post.  I enjoyed your selections, and I hope you enjoy mine.



  1. Mr. Grant, I love most music as I think is common here in South Louisiana. When I see a WWII movie with submarines, I think science fiction and when I see Moonlight Sonata like this, I believe Beethoven would be a rock star, perhaps.

  2. If you like something beyond simple rock, try symphonic heavy metal. This is an European type of music incorporating operatic, primarily female, vocals with choral backing and often complex scores. To start I suggest Nightwish -Ghost Love Score, Epica – Cry For The Moon, and Therion – Lemuria, all available on Youtube. All of these bands have been active for over 20 years and have large catalogs of music but these 3 cuts should give you a taste.

  3. Don't forget Emerson, Lake, & Palmer. They had very definite signs of classical training running through their music.

  4. I "discovered" rock music as my own music when I was 16. All of the rock that I truly liked, especially while stoned, is what I now know as progressive rock. It is the only rock that could compete with fusion jazz (which I also liked when I was 16) for my attention. Regular rock and pop was simply too boring to me.

  5. In about 1976, Jethro Tull gave a concert at Purdue University – their keyboard player warmed up backstage before the concert by playing classical piano pieces by Beethoven, Chopin and Mozart. He was very good – John Evan was the bloke, I had sneaked in and was posing as a lighting guy, went over and talked a bit with him. Got to watch the whole concert from the side of backstage, was really great.

  6. If you like the music analysis, you may like Rick Beato's YouTube channel. He's a music producer who has a playlist titled, "What makes this song great?" in which he goes into detail about the composing, arranging, and other factors involved in various songs.

    He also has videos in which he listens to the top ten songs on Spotify and critiques them.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *